Okanagan Business Journal
Diversified We Stand
Diversifying is one of the smartest moves a business can make. “It’s almost like an insurance policy,” says Sid Sidhu of Bella Vista Farm Market and Turtle Mountain Vineyards (formerly Bella Vista Winery).
Sidhu’s family has been operating Bella Vista Farm Market since 1987, starting with an apple orchard and over time adding soft fruits such as cherries and peaches. A few acres of vegetables rounds out the offering, although for the most part, the produce grown on the Vernon farm is sold wholesale.
There were significant losses until the Sidhus made the strategic changes to their methods of getting the product to market. This included in-house packing to lower expenses and keep the prices attractive to their wholesale clients. This savings enabled them to reinvest in the orchard and continue expansion.
Last June, they diversified again, this time selling 22 acres of apple orchard to purchase a 15 acre vineyard. The Bella Vista Winery, formerly owned by Larry Passmore, was purchased for $780,000. That is the price the Business Development Bank wanted requested to retrieve its investment into the property from so many years ago.
Passmore defaulted on the loan and was unable to get any more extensions. He attempted to sell the property on his own for $1.5 million, but failed to secure a private sale.
Once the transaction was complete and the Sidhus, along with three business partners, took over the winery, the real work began. Four months of TLC went into the existing vines: six acres of Marechal Foche, two acres of Pinot Gris, an acre of Gewurztraminer and the rest a mishmash of table grapes including Concorde. Collectively the acreage was providing little yield at the end of the growing season. Four tones of Marechal Foche was harvested from the six acres of plants, well below the expected yields of 1 tonne per acre.
After the efforts to save various vines proved unsuccessful, the decision was made to ‘start over’. Only two remaining acres of Marechal Foche, over 18 years old and still producing, were saved.
“The vines had been neglected, they were full of mildew and had a severe insect infestation. Beyond that we needed to replace the rotting posts, and the irrigation system,” explains Sidhu, as farm workers gently cover 1,100 new plants with nutrient rich soil.
“The soil itself is nearly perfect,” he continues. “Testing revealed it to be magnesium deficient, but it is easily repaired with a fertilizer blend.”
The new dual irrigation system has a regular drip line running down each row – 54,000 linear feet of irrigation hose and an overhead irrigation line. The contingency overhead line offers additional moisture for the beginning and end of the season and acts as a form of frost protection.
The Foche will be the only red grape grown at the revitalized vineyard. “The Foche will be our learning curve. It needs a lot of repair and maintenance. It’s almost like practice,” says Sidhu.
New plants consist of 3,000 Gewurtztraminer, 4,200 Pinot Gris and 3,000 Auxerrois, essentially the same grapes grown on the vineyard. It will be three years before the new vines will yield a harvest.
Although the Sidhus are new to grapes, they are confident their own extensive knowledge of the tree fruit industry, augmented by consultants and talk with other vineyard managers will create a successful vineyard.
“The hard part is, everyone has a different opinion on how to do this. We hired three different consultants who all had different opinions. It doesn’t mean anyone is right or wrong, just that there is a lot of really good information out there, and we need to extract what we think will work here.”
The rest of the winery will come along while the vines mature. Sidhu says, “Start with the vines. While these are growing over the next three years we can do the rest, including restoring the building, which although is structurally sound, desperately needs a facelift. We will make this a beautiful, functional place for weddings, parties, conferences.”
Ideally, keeping the Bella Vista name would have knitted the two agricultural businesses together but the public opinion argued against that. “We mention the name Bella Vista Winery and people essentially turn the other way,” says Sidhu.
Instead, the name Turtle Mountain Vineyards is being registered. “Turtle Mountain is located behind us here at the winery. When we first came to the area, we would often find a few turtles every year, migrating from the little mountain down to Okanagan Lake.”
The Sidues run the farm and vineyard as a family, with many long hours put in to yield a better result. The business’ mission statement is “Actively Preserving BC Farmland.” The whole Sidhu family believes its about the soil, the produce and creating sustainability.
“My father likes to say that there isn’t water running through the irrigation system on our farms, it’s his blood,” says Sidhu, explaining the heart, soul and efforts put in by his family and their workers.
Government Siphons off the Water of Life
Okanagan Business Journal
The sweet smell of success is hampered by bureaucracy and small mindedness on behalf of the government and its liquor control board according to Frank Deiter of Okanagan Spirits.
When Deiter emigrated to Canada he saw the Okanagan’s rich fruit industry as lacking value added products. Once in the Okanagan, Deiter saw a chance to produce a brandy product similar to what 30,000 German companies do back in Europe. The brandies he calls Eaux de Vie – the water of life. “We are the first fruit brandy distillery in B.C., not comparable to grain alcohol producers who make 60,000 litres per day.”
By using the abundance of local product, he determined that he could build a boutique distillery, creating a variety of high quality beverages for food processing as well as local and tourist consumption. His business plan includes delicate sipping brandies, as well as quality cooking brandies to be used in locally manufactured products like sausage, preserves, pates, chocolates and many others.
Okanagan Spirits began production in October 2004, after delays caused by too many government departments not communicating. In a business case of the chicken and the egg getting his liquor license required him to have a PST number, but that was held up because he wasn’t selling anything, which he couldn’t do without a liquor license. The issue was finally resolved by a forward thinking government employee.
All documents in hand, distillation finally began. His first bottling year was exceptionally good in terms of international recognition, with three awards at the World Spirit Awards in Klagenfurt, Austria in March 2005.
Deiter has 18 products bottled and ready to be sold, however, only two are available through the LDB and private liquor stores. Ten products in total are registered, meaning they can be sold at the retail store attached to the distillery.
The other eight products are waiting to be registered, which, says Deiter, is not as onerous a process as calculating the taxes once they become available for sale.
To calculate the final price of any spirit, the base cost of the product is increased by 10% pst, 3% alcohol tax, 7% gst and then a 167% markup by the provincial government, which is calculated after the Duty In federal tax is added. The Duty In tax is $11.066/ltr based on 100% proof.
The B.C. government bases its markup on the total product, raw materials, labour, marketing, and bottling costs, and taxes on taxes. Deiter found a supplier for a beautiful bottle with hand blown glass fruit in the bottom, but because of the huge tax markups, the raw bottle cost would have priced the product well beyond the market’s ability to bear.
Just the fruit he uses runs between $5 and $20 per litre of alcohol. With the markup his 375 ml bottles sell for between $40 and $90 dollars.
A simpler tax regime in Alberta is attracting Deiter. “Alberta is a great interest to me, since the provincial tax is based on the volume of alcohol alone.” The volume-based tax system gives Okanagan Spirits products a much more level playing field.
B.C. taxes on wine and spirit production are similar however exhaustive lobbying from the wineries has allowed for some exceptions by the government on wine pricing. Wineries with attached retail stores must sell their wines for the same price that is listed in the LDB, however, the markup on the wines doesn’t go to the LDB, it remains with the winery.
Deiter, who has researched the issue claims, “The LDB makes zero dollars on any wine not sold in a Liquor Distribution Branch.” He asks that his product, a high end, locally grown and produced beverage, be given the same leverage.
In a letter dated July 28, 2005, Solicitor General John Les complimented Deiter on his venture, but said “I do not believe, however, that it would be appropriate to extend LDB markup policies for wineries to the distilling industry at the present time.” Les offers no explanation as to why wine production is accorded preferential treatment to other liquor produced in the province.
To date there are three licensed distilleries with onsite stores in B.C., and three pending.
Another market Deiter would like to compete in is imported, alcohol-based flavourings like Kirsch, known as “aromas” in the industry. He says there is definitely a market among local commercial bakeries, sausage houses and other food processors for these products.
John van der Lieck of Oyama Sausage says, “We would love to use Okanagan Spirit products in all our pertinent products, however, at this time, the tax man is giving the importers a tax advantage over the local product that is substantial. Higher quality always fetches a better price, but our customers are price conscious too, so there has to be a reasonable approach to effort and result.”
According to Article 62 of the Liquor Control Act, these extracts are considered nonalcoholic beverages, even though they contain some alcohol. The Act explains this by saying:
<block>“These are toiletries, such as mouthwash; cooking preparations, such as vanilla extract and liqueur-filled chocolates; cleaning and disinfecting agents, such as Lysol; baking flavours and extracts; and “industrial strength” flavouring agents. Most are automatically exempted because they contain enough ingredients other than liquor to stop them being consumed as alcoholic beverages.”</block>
This classification allows these products to come in without the massive taxes placed on alcohol products. He can not achieve a similar exemption status despite a seven month battle to get his products recognized as food flavouring agents.
The price difference is so huge that it has shut him out of the food flavouring market. His bottle of Virginiana Kirsch retails for $87 (375 mL) whereas a non-beverage alcohol is sold at $26 per litre.
The price structure is forcing Deiter to expand. What Deiter originally saw as a small boutique distillery is being scaled up into large scale manufacturing, which he says is necessary to pay the bills. Survival depends on creating high volume sales. With that in mind, Okanagan Spirits’ Eaux de Vie is now available in Manitoba, and will soon hit the shelves in Alberta, Saskatchewan, Ontario and Quebec.
On the international front Deiter will also be taking more of his unique products to the European stage, including his 2005 Apricot Brandy, which is his best hope for a second gold medal.
