Fighting it out at work
Workplace violence is often overlooked, sometimes with serious consequences
Okanagan Business Journal
It was something out of Hollywood; a disgruntled, 55 year old employee goes home in the middle of the day, retrieves his handgun and returns to his office to kill two coworkers before turning the gun on himself. But the residents of Kamloops could not walk out of this theatre on October 15, 2002.
Instead, they had to deal with the aftermath, including the realization that ‘going postal’ was no longer something that only happened in the movies, or south of the border.
Richard Anderson’s actions may have brought to light the increasing severity of violence in the workplace amongst coworkers, but workplace violence, while usually not that extreme, is much more common that most people want to admit.
But worker-to-worker violence is not that much of a problem states Corporal Henry Proce of the Vernon RCMP. “The workplace is not conducive to violence. Fighting with your coworker will likely cost you your job.”
Proce may see it that way because police are rarely brought in for worker-to-worker confrontations.
Just like days of old where duelling for honour was accepted, provocations or invitations to fight that result in physical altercation, are ignored because, he says “there is a verbal agreement to assault each other, [so] there will be no charges.”
Proce feels that more often cases of workplace violence occur between worker and customer.
Customers that become agitated do so without the same risk of losing their job.
Even when the police know about it, they may not be able to do anything. “There was an incident where an assault occurred on a female lift operator, [on the local ski hill],”explains Proce. “The skier was confronted for using a fraudulent pass, and the male skier became agitated and pushed her to the ground. The police laid charges, but the crown didn’t approve them for court.”
More common are assaults involving delays to the traveling public.
The owner of an Okanagan-based flagging, who wishes to remain anonymous, shares that on an average day, with 12 flaggers working different areas, there will be at least one to two incidents reported back to her office.
Provocations include verbal abuse, tossed garbage, spitting on flaggers, and in one case, a driver touched the flaggers leg with his bumper and moved forward, forcing the flagger out of the way.
The owner says these kinds of incidents are by no means unique to her company, and in fact will occur with all flaggers throughout the country.
She recounts her own worst experience, which occurred on a typical, quiet residential street where asphalt was being laid.
It needed to be rolled before vehicles could be allowed to pass. The time needed was brief, but too long for one angry home owner, who left the lineup and drove straight toward her before applying the brakes. He then pulle around her, over the freshly poured (and now ruined) asphalt, and into his driveway. He then left his car, and went nose-to-nose with her.
She recalls his threats: “I will take you out! How dare you tell me where I can and cannot drive!” The police were brought in, and she left for the rest of the day, too shaken up to continue.
Even in cases where the RCMP or other police are brought in, statistics are difficult to determine as assaults are categorized by nature (common assault, aggravated assault, assault causing bodily harm) rather than by location,(workplace or home).
Debra Critchley of the Vernon & District Women’s Centre notes some employers have put in safety measures to reduce risk, like window barriers to separate clients from government ministry staff.
But in many cases, such protection is not possible where interaction is necessary, like hospitals and care facilities.
In some health fields the violence may not be intentional, but even when higher staff to patient ratios reduce the opportunity for, and severity of a violent attack, they can’t eliminate it.
Mike Clarke, Occupational Health and Safety Chair for the BCGEU, whose own field is mental health, explains that for years the unspoken rule seemed to be that as part of your job , you should “expect to be yelled at or physically attacked”.
His role with the BCGEU has involved him in extensive surveys and research asking workers if they have been threatened verbally or physically, and why there is a ‘culture of non-reporting’.
Clarke feels there is a ‘strange area of denial’, amongst employers intent on racking up safety days rather than dealing wit the mostly minor incidents that carry the risk of escalation.
He complains that too often staff training focuses completely on the tasks of the job, but fails to provide policies and procedures for staff to follow when they feel they have been a victim.
WorksafeBC statistics for 2000 – 2004 reveal that as an accident type, violence/force ranks 13 out of 19 categories. j
Aside from physical and mental trauma, it is costly, and likely more so than these figures reveal given the habit of underreporting that most safety experts have noted.
Violence accounts for 2% of claims, days lost and money paid out. That is a significant sum, costing $65.5 million of the $3.4 billion paid out in the past five years.
Those costs are likely to keep increasing.
Although reported acts of violence have grown steadily almost every year from 1994 to 2003, they took a substantial 30% drop last year.
While the one year reversal is a nice surprise, few are confident it is more than an anomalous blip in the trend.
Although Proce feels most cases of workplace violence involve males, the statistics don’t bear that out. Of all the accident types, workplace violence is the only one where genders are equal.
While every other accident type displays ratios of 1:2 to 1:11, of women to men, violence is as likely to be directed at male workers just as often as females.
Clarke says employees and employers do not have to accept violence and there are things that can be done to reduce incidents.
The BCGEU has developed a training module for both management and union employees, assisting them with identifying the risks in their industry and jobsite, as well as developing a plan of action. “We want them to prepare for the worse and hope for the best.”
WorksafeBC also has an information booklet available to employers and staff, entitled ‘Take Care: How to develop and implement a workplace violence prevention program’.
It is available through the WorksafeBC Website at worksafebc.com . They can be reached at 888-922-2768.
